Compare the pros and cons of metal and shingle roofs before deciding which to choose with Watkins Construction & Roofing. If you’re looking to install a new roof, the number of options available on the market can easily overwhelm you. However, the two most popular types of roofing materials among homeowners are metal and shingles. The right choice for you will depend on your personal preferences, your budget, and your precise needs. In this brief guide on the comparison of metal roofs versus shingles, our experts will provide you with all the information you need to make an informed decision.
To make the right decision, it is important to understand the benefits and features of each type. There are pros and cons to both metal roofs and shingle roofs, and these differences may influence your decision on which one to choose. If you’re trying to choose between metal and shingles, this comparison guide is for you.
Metal Roof vs. Shingle Roofs: A Variety of Finish Options
Both metal roofs, as well as shingle roofs, are highly sought after by roofers and property owners due to their stunning finishing options. These options not only enhance the appearance of a building but also add a unique and visually appealing touch to the overall look of the property.
Shingle roofs come in a range of styles, including traditional and those that imitate other types of materials including wood shakes, tiles, and even slate. You can also choose from various styles such as terra cotta, which is suitable for Mediterranean homes, or scalloped edges, which are perfect for Victorian homes.
Alternatively, metal roofs also come in a variety of styles and can be made of aluminum, copper, zinc, tin, or galvanized metal. These materials can be used to create traditional or contemporary designs, making metal roofs suitable for sheds, barns, modern homes, and even complex structures.
Metal Roofs Offer Exceptional Durability
Metal roofs offer significantly more durability than shingle roofs. They can provide homeowners with efficient protection for up to 50 years and even beyond. And some manufacturers offer warranties for the same length of time. With proper maintenance, metal roofs can even last for up to 70 years. This incredibly long lifespan and minimal maintenance of these roofs make them a popular choice for homeowners looking for long-term roofing solutions. Although metal roofs offer long-lasting durability, they may be prone to damage from extreme weather events such as falling tree branches and hail.
Shingle Roofs are More Affordable Upfront
When deciding on a new roofing installation or roof repair, the cost is a significant consideration. Shingle roofs tend to have a lower upfront cost in comparison to metal roofing systems. On average, the cost of shingle roofs can range from $100 to $200 for every 100 square feet. On the other hand, the cost of a typical metal roof can be anywhere between $120 and $900 for every 100 square feet. Furthermore, different materials have different installation costs, and metal roofing installation requires highly skilled and specialized labor, and therefore can be more cost intensive.
Metal Roofs are More Eco-friendly
If you are interested in reducing your environmental impact, a metal roof may be a suitable option for your home. Metal roofing systems are often manufactured using recycled materials. In addition to being environmentally friendly, metal roofs are also effective at heat management. They have an excellent ability to reflect heat and UV rays away from the house, which can help you save some serious money on your utility bills every month. Overall, metal roofs are highly energy-efficient, durable, and recyclable, providing multiple benefits for homeowners.
Asphalt shingle roofs, on the other hand, have a limited lifespan and can easily become loose, requiring frequent replacements. Additionally, they are not recyclable, leading to approximately 20 billion pounds of them being sent to U.S. landfills each year, causing a great deal of environmental damage.
Asphalt Shingles Offer Ease of Installation and Repair
Asphalt shingles are a cost-effective option for roofing due to their low purchase and installation cost, as well as their easy and inexpensive repairs. These shingles are among the most affordable roofing materials available and can easily be purchased for repair/replacement purposes. Additionally, their repair can be easily performed using some simple methods, as no specialized skills are required.
Unlike shingle roofs, metal roofs are costlier and require specialized expertise for installation and repair. Attempting DIY repairs on a metal roof may not be an option due to the high risk of error. Additionally, the cost of installing and repairing a metal roof is typically higher than that of a shingle roof.
In conclusion:
As a homeowner, it is important to consider the key factors that come into play when choosing a roofing material. These may include budget, repair, durability, installation costs, and maintenance requirements. By weighing the pros and cons of different materials, you can make an informed decision about which one will best meet your needs.
For example, metal roofs offer better durability than shingle roofs, but factors like the climate in your location may also impact your final choice. If you need assistance with your roofing project, Watkins Construction & Roofing has skilled and experienced roofers who can provide you with comprehensive solutions for optimum protection and energy efficiency.
For more information, you can reach Watkins Construction & Roofing at 601-488-3179. We service areas in Jackson, Flowood, Clinton, and Ridgeland, MS.